Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast

Episode 170: Previously On Unnatural - The Crimes That Made Our Season

In this special episode of Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast, we’re rewinding the tape and fast-forwarding through the latest developments in some of the most unforgettable cases we’ve covered this season. From tragic conclusions to bizarre new twists, we’re checking in on cases that made headlines—and the ones that kept us up at night.
Get updates on:🔹 Carly Gregg, the Mississippi Mom Killer, and her push for an appeal🔹 Tyler Goodrich, whose heartbreaking story took a tragic turn🔹 Maxwell Anderson, now convicted and awaiting sentencing🔹 Travis Decker, still on the run after allegedly murdering his three daughters🔹 The Bell Mountain Twins, whose mysterious deaths were finally explained, maybe?🔹 Luigi Mangione, and the upcoming "Trial of the Century"🔹 Ryan Borgwardt, now behind bars with an annulled marriage
Travis Decker's Possible Altered Appearance
Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast on YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 169: The Manhunt for Travis Decker

32-year-old Travis Decker is currently on the run from state and federal authorities in Washington, after allegedly murdering his three daughters following a shared custody visit.In this episode, we'll explore Travis's past, his struggles with mental illness, and the clues that may point to where he's headed.
 
Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast on YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 168: Chelsea Perkins - The Vigilante Vet

It happened in March 2021, at Cuyahoga Valley National Park - nestled between Cleveland and Akron, Ohio. That's where adult entertainer and former U.S. Coast Guard member Chelsea Perkins shot 31-year-old Matthew Dunmire - seemingly in an act of revenge.
Chelsea had accused Matthew of rape four years earlier, but no charges were ever filed.
In this episode, we dive deep into Chelsea's meticulous plan for retribution, what unfolded next, and how Matthew's own parents sought a chilling form of vengeance... on Chelsea.
 
Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast on YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 167: The First Date Killer - Maxwell Anderson

In April 2024, 19-year-old Sade Robinson of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, went missing after going on a first date with Maxwell Anderson. Just a few days later, the first body parts began turning up at a local park.In this episode, we look at the events that transpired before Sade met her tragic demise and what might unfold at the trial of Maxwell Anderson, which begins this week.
Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast on YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 166: The Nebraska & Montana Murder-Suicides

On this episode, we look back on two tragic murder-suicides in the U.S. that took place within two days of each other over Mother's Day weekend. But these weren't your run-of-the-mill murder-suicides — these were familicides. And in both instances, it was the father who took the lives of the mother and the children.Our first case takes us to the small town of Cozad, Nebraska, as we look at the tragic deaths of Bailey Koch and her family. In our second case, we head to Kalispell, Montana, where we examine the gruesome demise of Katie Hartley and her children.
Larissa Strong joins Andy on this episode, which will also be broadcast on our brand-new YouTube Channel. We encourage you to subscribe, as new videos will be added every week!
 
Hailey's Legacy Website
Katie Hartley & Family GoFundMe 
Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast on YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 165: Body at the Bottom of a Stairwell - Caitlin Tracey

In October 2024, 36-year-old Caitlin Tracey's lifeless body was found at the bottom of a stairwell in a luxury high-rise building. Was it an accident... or something far more sinister? In this episode, we trace Caitlin's final months, the red flags that came before, and the bizarre investigation that followed.
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 164: The Murder That Wasn't - Emily Steinhoff James

In March of 2024, Emily Steinhoff James went with her sister, Hilary Lombardi, to the home of Dorian Thomas to pick up Hilary's daughter in a custody dispute. Tragically, Emily wouldn't leave the home alive. This is the story of the life and death of Emily, as told by one of her friends, Larissa Strong.
 
Hailey's Legacy Website
Emily's Family's GoFundMe
Emily's Story Website
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 163: The Kidnapping of Virginia Piper

Join Andy, Emily, and Rian for the 4th-anniversary special of Unnatural!
In this episode, we're going back to where it all began for us, Minnesota. And in 1972, one of the most infamous (and successful) kidnappings in U.S. history took place within its borders. 
Virginia Piper was the 49-year-old wife of Harry Piper, an extremely wealthy CEO in the Twin Cities. When she was kidnapped on a warm July afternoon, her abductors were demanding a million-dollar ransom.
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com
 

Episode 162: The Vanishing of Jodi Huisentruit

She was the news—then she became it.Iowa T.V. Anchor Jodi Huisentruit was running late for work in 1995… and vanished without a trace. Her car? Found in the lot. Her keys? On the ground. Her story? Still unsolved.
Was it a stalker? A secret? Or something far more sinister?This is the case that shook an entire state—and still haunts it.
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com

Episode 161: The Suspicious Death of Buffalo Jim Barrier

He was a beloved Las Vegas icon—part mechanic, part pro wrestling promoter, full-on personality. But when Buffalo Jim Barrier was found dead in a seedy motel in 2008, questions swirled. Was it a heart attack… or something far more sinister? In this episode, we dig into the wild life and suspicious death of a man who stood up to Vegas mobsters and may have paid the ultimate price.
This is the story of Buffalo Jim Barrier.
Special thanks to my friend Kim from MustSeeLasVegas for joining me on today's episode! You can follow Kim on TikTok and YouTube using the links below.
MustSeeLasVegas TikTok, MustSeeLasVegas YouTube
--
Connect with us!
Instagram: @unnaturalthepodcast
Facebook: Unnatural: A True Crime Podcast
Email: unnaturalthepodcast@gmail.com